Opponents of government restrictions on personal freedoms during the COVID-19 pandemic argue that lockdowns have taken a greater toll on the publics health than the disease itself.
They cite factors, such as missed opportunities to screen for illnesses and provide vaccinations, lengthening waiting times for consultations and surgical procedures, and the mental health toll of loneliness and isolation.
People sometimes sum these up as the cure is worse than the disease.
Writing in BMJ Global Health, public health experts emphasize that it is challenging to disentangle the health effects of lockdowns from the health effects of the pandemic.
However, their own analysis suggests that it is unlikely that government interventions have been worse for public health at least in the short term than the pandemic itself.
They considered not only overall mortality rates but also disruptions to health services, mental health effects, and the number of suicides.
The research was an international collaboration between scientists in Australia, Denmark, the United Kingdom, and the United States.
To tease apart the health effects of the pandemic and lockdown restrictions, the researchers turned to the World Mortality Dataset.
The dataset includes figures for excess mortality in 94 countries between the start of the pandemic in 2020 and the middle of 2021.
It defines excess mortality as the difference between the actual number of deaths and the predicted number, given trends before the pandemic.
In Australia and New Zealand, which imposed several lockdowns but experienced relatively few COVID-19 cases, the researchers found no excess mortality during 2020.
If it were true that the cure is worse than the disease, lockdowns would have increased death rates in these countries compared with previous years, even in the absence of severe outbreaks.
The researchers found a similar story in South Korea, Taiwan, and Thailand, which imposed lockdowns despite having few or no COVID-19 cases.
These countries either recorded no excess mortality or relatively small increases.
On the flip side, countries that imposed few restrictions, including Brazil, Sweden, and Russia, have recorded large numbers of excess deaths throughout the pandemic.
[I]f areas that locked down but had low COVID-19 cases did not see deaths from other causes rise, lockdowns themselves cannot be the cause of deaths per se, said lead author Gideon Meyerowitz-Katz, an epidemiologist at the School of Health and Society at the University of Wollongong in Australia.
It is possible that they have had mixed benefits, but the evidence is not consistent with a situation where lockdowns cause large numbers of deaths in the short term, he told Medical News Today.
The authors emphasize that the possibility remains that lockdowns have detrimental effects on health, both in the short and long term.
For example, a U.K. study found an increase in heart attacks within the community during the first wave of COVID-19. However, the research was unable to determine whether government restrictions or COVID-19 caused this growth.
Another study suggested that missed cancer screenings could lead to a large increase in cancer deaths in the U.K. But reduced screening could also result from the reallocation of healthcare staff to pandemic-related work.
Commenting on the new analysis for the Science Media Centre in London, Mark Woolhouse, professor of infectious disease epidemiology at the University of Edinburgh in the U.K., said:
The authors reach the unsurprising conclusion that the short-term impact of lockdown on mortality rates is considerably less than the impact of COVID-19, while correctly acknowledging that it is extremely difficult to disentangle the direct and indirect effects of either. This is a useful exercise but falls far short of demonstrating that the cure will not prove to be worse than the disease in the long term.
Other researchers are concerned that the long-term consequences of the disease could be far ranging, particularly with potentially lasting effects on the brain.
The authors report that there is consistent and robust evidence that government measures to control COVID-19 have not led to increased deaths from suicide.
They acknowledge that there is also abundant evidence that mental health has declined since the onset of the pandemic.
But they emphasize that it is challenging to disentangle the effects of lockdown and the pandemic itself, which has led to anxiety about infection and a high burden of bereavement.
Dean Burnett, Ph.D., honorary research associate at Cardiff Psychology School in the U.K., told MNT that the focus on case numbers, death rates, and hospital occupancy risked sidelining the pandemics toll on mental health.
Dr. Burnett, who was not involved in the new research, lost his own father to COVID-19 in 2020.
The raw numbers are useful for tracking the progress and pattern of the pandemic, but every one of those numbers is actually a complex individual human, with all the emotional connections and relationships that entails, he said.
As a result, their sickness or death will have a wide range of negative consequences for the well-being of those around them.
It is important to note that the study was unable to include information about the impact of long COVID due to the lack of comparable data across countries.
Long COVID, or post-COVID syndrome the persistence of symptoms for 3 months or more affects around 1 in 10 people with COVID-19.
The fewer people who develop COVID-19, the fewer people will be affected by long COVID, therefore pushing the balance further towards the disease being worse than lockdowns.
For live updates on the latest developments regarding the novel coronavirus and COVID-19, click here.
Go here to see the original:
COVID-19: Are lockdowns worse than the disease? - Medical News Today
- 15 more Utahns die of COVID-19 in the past day - Salt Lake Tribune - September 23rd, 2021
- Moderna CEO says COVID-19 pandemic could be over in a year - Fox Business - September 23rd, 2021
- Severe COVID-19 may trigger autoimmune conditions; New variants cause more virus in the air - Reuters - September 23rd, 2021
- She's an Anchorage nurse. Her brother died of COVID-19 at the hospital where she works. - Anchorage Daily News - September 23rd, 2021
- Americans who relied most on Trump for COVID-19 news among least likely to be vaccinated - Pew Research Center - September 23rd, 2021
- What Is the R.1 COVID Variant? Experts Share What It Could Mean for the U.S. - Prevention.com - September 23rd, 2021
- Influenza Season Begins With Strained Critical Care Facilities and Staffing from COVID-19 - AustinTexas.gov - September 23rd, 2021
- Return to school has caused a surge in covid-19 cases in under-vaccinated counties - The Economist - September 23rd, 2021
- Houston Health Department to offer on campus COVID-19 testing in schools - City of Houston - September 23rd, 2021
- COVID-19 live updates: Hospitalizations reach another all-time high in Iowa for 2021 - ABC News - September 23rd, 2021
- COVID-19: What you need to know about the coronavirus pandemic on 23 September - World Economic Forum - September 23rd, 2021
- Loveland clinic owner refused to stop overstating effectiveness of alleged COVID-19 cures, AG says - 9News.com KUSA - September 23rd, 2021
- Nearly 10000 new COVID-19 cases reported by Ohio schools this week - NBC4 WCMH-TV - September 23rd, 2021
- Funeral procession planned Friday for FHP Trooper who died of COVID-19 - Wink News - September 23rd, 2021
- Jonas Brothers concert to require COVID-19 test or vaccination - WSYR - September 23rd, 2021
- FCPS grieves the loss of 15-year-old sophomore to COVID-19 - LEX18 Lexington KY News - September 23rd, 2021
- China imposes local lockdowns as COVID-19 cases surge - September 17th, 2021
- Exhaustion, regret in the halls of hospitals as COVID-19 continues to threaten Michigan - Detroit Free Press - September 17th, 2021
- Texas doctors, seeing unprecedented numbers of pregnant patients with COVID-19, urge pregnant people to get vaccinated - The Texas Tribune - September 17th, 2021
- Alaska once had the highest vaccination rate. Now it's in a COVID-19 crisis. - ABC News - September 17th, 2021
- Inside the COVID-19 outbreak sweeping through the Red Sox - The Boston Globe - September 17th, 2021
- Maine reports 1390 COVID-19 cases, 52 active outbreaks in schools - pressherald.com - September 17th, 2021
- Idaho Is Rationing Health Care Statewide As It Struggles To Cope With COVID-19 - NPR - September 17th, 2021
- Lee Health treating 333 COVID-19 patients as of Friday morning - Wink News - September 17th, 2021
- 3000 Health Care Workers In France Have Been Suspended For Not Getting A COVID Shot - NPR - September 17th, 2021
- New Hanover County reports record-high 37 COVID-19 deaths in the past week - Communications and Outreach - Communications and Outreach - North... - September 17th, 2021
- MSDH: 15 pregnant women have died from COVID-19 in Mississippi - Northeast Mississippi Daily Journal - September 17th, 2021
- Covid-19 Rapid Testing in U.S. Lags Behind Other Countries in Delta Wave - The Wall Street Journal - September 17th, 2021
- How low exactly is COVID-19 transmission in the San Francisco Bay Area right now? - SFGate - September 17th, 2021
- Trial over COVID-19 outbreak in Austria's 'Ibiza of the Alps' begins - Reuters - September 17th, 2021
- Why California Has One of the Lowest Covid-19 Rates in the Nation - The New York Times - September 17th, 2021
- Wrongly convicted man dies of Covid-19, nine years after he was exonerated - CNN - September 17th, 2021
- Beijing 2022 Games to have rigorous COVID-19 measures-IOC - Reuters - September 17th, 2021
- Fear is our worst enemy when it comes to COVID-19 and children | Opinion - The Philadelphia Inquirer - September 17th, 2021
- More Than 1,200 Mass. Kids Test Positive For COVID-19 This Week - CBS Boston - September 17th, 2021
- COVID-19 Daily Update 9-16-2021 - West Virginia Department of Health and Human Resources - September 17th, 2021
- A journey inside the human body as it goes to war with COVID-19 - USA TODAY - September 17th, 2021
- 54 new COVID-19 cases Thursday, 2 new clusters - The Garden Island - September 17th, 2021
- 1 in every 500 US residents have died of Covid-19 - CNN - September 15th, 2021
- COVID is on its way to becoming just another virus ... - September 15th, 2021
- In her obituary, a family says a mother's Covid-19 death could have been prevented if more people were vaccinated - CNN - September 15th, 2021
- When will the COVID-19 pandemic end? McKinsey experts explain | World Economic Forum - World Economic Forum - September 15th, 2021
- Here's What Worries Air Travelers More Than Getting Covid-19 - Forbes - September 15th, 2021
- Betadines maker says you shouldnt ingest it for COVID-19 treatment or any other reason - WNCT - September 15th, 2021
- 14 new COVID-19 cases & one nonresident death reported for Juneau City and Borough of Juneau - City and Borough of Juneau - September 15th, 2021
- DHEC Updates Its Statewide School COVID-19 Reporting to Include Quarantined and Isolated Students and School Employees - SCDHEC - September 15th, 2021
- New Mexico health, education officials to address states COVID-19 trends Wednesday - KRQE News 13 - September 15th, 2021
- Researchers Say Some People Have Developed Superhuman Immunity Against COVID-19 - CBS Dallas / Fort Worth - September 15th, 2021
- COVID-19 vaccines: Here's how to spot misinformation on social media and fight it - Detroit Free Press - September 15th, 2021
- How the U.S. Nailed the Economic Response to Covid-19 - The Wall Street Journal - September 15th, 2021
- Charlie Baker says a lot of people got the COVID-19 outbreak in Provincetown all wrong - Boston.com - September 15th, 2021
- COVID-19 in South Dakota: 568 total new cases; Death toll increases to 2,093; Active cases at 7,364 - KELOLAND.com - September 15th, 2021
- Majority in U.S. Says Public Health Benefits of COVID-19 Restrictions Worth the Costs, Even as Large Shares Also See Downsides - Pew Research Center - September 15th, 2021
- Federated learning for predicting clinical outcomes in patients with COVID-19 - Nature.com - September 15th, 2021
- Colorado radio host who urged boycott of vaccines dies of Covid-19 - The Guardian - September 15th, 2021
- Regular COVID-19 testing in Austin schools could be more effective than mask wearing, UT analysis shows - KXAN.com - September 15th, 2021
- Color-coded school thresholds added to Utah COVID-19 dashboard | Utah Department of Health - Utah Department of Health - September 15th, 2021
- Bartholomew County reporting three new COVID-19 deaths - The Republic - September 15th, 2021
- Increasing COVID-19 patients having negative impacts on ambulance response times - KPTV.com - September 15th, 2021
- Elementary school closes because of COVID-19 and other illnesses - East Idaho News - September 15th, 2021
- FDA Will Follow The Science On COVID-19 Vaccines For Young Children | FDA - FDA.gov - September 15th, 2021
- COVID Dashboard - September 13th, 2021
- Coronavirus in the U.S.: Latest Map and Case Count - September 13th, 2021
- COVID-19 in Arkansas: Hospitalizations down for the fifth straight day - KARK - September 13th, 2021
- First known A&M student reported to have died from COVID-19 complications - Texas A&M The Battalion - September 13th, 2021
- Parents Grow Increasingly Concerned As COVID-19 Cases Continue To Rise - CBS Baltimore - September 13th, 2021
- Study finds who may get more severe illness from a COVID-19 breakthrough case - SFGate - September 13th, 2021
- Like 9/11, COVID-19s toll set to shape a generation - NJ Spotlight - September 13th, 2021
- Austin Arts & Music festival latest event canceled due to COVID-19 while others resume - KXAN.com - September 13th, 2021
- The COVID-19 surge is overwhelming emergency rooms across Virginia - Virginia Mercury - September 13th, 2021
- MDHHS issues guidance for parents with children exposed to COVID-19 - WLNS - September 13th, 2021
- Low incidence of breakthrough infections at YNHHS highlights importance of COVID-19 vaccines - Yale Daily News - September 13th, 2021
- Alaska's COVID-19 hospitalizations have hit new all-time highs. Here's what that number really reflects. - Anchorage Daily News - September 13th, 2021
- COVID-19 cases among children in Oregon, Lane County higher than ever during pandemic - The Register-Guard - September 13th, 2021
- VERIFY: Do NFL fans have to be vaccinated for COVID-19 to attend games? - WCNC.com - September 13th, 2021
- Regeneron, effective in treating COVID-19, arrives in Kitsap County - Kitsap Sun - September 13th, 2021
- Despite early jump on COVID-19, tribes lose a brother and a son - OPB News - September 13th, 2021
- DHHR adds more than 2,200 COVID-19 cases on Sunday - West Virginia MetroNews - September 13th, 2021
- Bidens Covid-19 Vaccine Mandate Further Stresses Supply of Rapid Tests - The Wall Street Journal - September 13th, 2021
- Travel and Covid-19 Testing: What to Know if Youre Flying or Taking a Cruise - The Wall Street Journal - September 13th, 2021