A COVID-19 home test in the U.S. comes with a swab to swirl in the nostrils. But some users say they're swabbing the throat too even though that's not what the instructions say to do. "They may stab themselves," cautions Dr. Janet Woodcock, acting head of the Food and Drug Administration. Angus Mordant/Bloomberg via Getty Images hide caption
A COVID-19 home test in the U.S. comes with a swab to swirl in the nostrils. But some users say they're swabbing the throat too even though that's not what the instructions say to do. "They may stab themselves," cautions Dr. Janet Woodcock, acting head of the Food and Drug Administration.
Lots of folks on Twitter say that swabbing your throat in addition to your nose may be a better way of using your COVID-19 testing kit to detect the omicron variant. Is this true?
If you've used a do-it-yourself COVID-19 home test in the U.S. the "antigen" rapid tests that promise results in 15 minutes or so you know the drill. You typically swirl a cotton swab around in your nostrils, mix it with some liquid and then drop it on a test strip to await the results: positive or negative for the coronavirus.
But in recent weeks, there has been an online debate about where to stick that cotton swab. Although the directions specify a nasal swab on U.S. products, some medical professionals believe the test is more effective at detecting the coronavirus, and specifically the omicron variant, if the kit's swab is used in the throat and/or cheek in addition to the nose.
Why did this hack emerge and is there any medical science to back it up?
The idea of a throat swab is not in and of itself a radical step. Even though antigen test kits in the U.S. are designed for a nasal swab, home tests are designed for a throat swab in other countries in Canada and the U.K., for example.
The idea of improvising with a throat swab is connected to the omicron variant, which was identified in late November and has swept the world. Researchers increasingly believe omicron may replicate in the throat before the nose.
That was one of the findings of a study conducted at the University of Cape Town in South Africa. Researchers examined the ability of PCR tests to detect the variant by comparing diagnostic tests for 382 symptomatic COVID-19 patients who weren't hospitalized. In patients with the delta variant of the coronavirus, saliva swabs detected the virus 71% of the time, while nasal swabs found it 100% of the time. But in patients with omicron, researchers found the reverse: Saliva swabs detected the virus 100% of the time, while nasal swabs caught it 86% of the time.
The research has not been peer reviewed. And the tests used in the study were PCR tests, not antigen tests. (PCR tests are the gold standard and are administered typically in a health care facility; antigen tests are less precise and can be done at home. See this story for details on the differences.)
Nonetheless, the South African study has led some epidemiologists and immunologists in the U.S. to experiment with antigen tests by swabbing their throats or cheeks in addition to the nose when administering a self-test.
That's not an authorized use of the kits, reminds the Food and Drug Administration, which regulates the kits: "FACT: When it comes to at-home rapid antigen #COVID19 tests, those swabs are for your nose and not your throat," it said in a tweet issued on Jan. 7.
And even proponents of the throat swab stop short of endorsing the practice for the public without a green light from the FDA.
One of the most often quoted voices in favor of throat swabbing is Dr. Michael Mina, formerly an epidemiologist and immunologist at the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health and now the chief science officer at the testing company eMed. He has tweeted: "We should be rigorously looking into throat swabs to add some level of sensitivity" and "Throat swab + nasal may improve chances a swab picks up virus."
But Mina has gone on to tweet that the FDA was right to warn the public not to go against manufacturer's directions: "Telling US public not to go against directions is the *right* thing to do."
"The tests haven't been designed to do [throat swabs], so we don't know whether there are false positives or negatives," agrees Dr. Jill Weatherhead, assistant professor of adult and pediatric infectious diseases at Baylor College of Medicine. "It logically makes sense that you'd want to do it, but that's not how [the tests have] been developed or tested."
One potential problem could be the thicker viscosity of throat saliva, says Dr. Yuka Manabe, associate director of global health research and innovation and a professor of medicine at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health. It's possible the sample would need to be filtered first, she says, to produce an accurate result.
That's not necessarily a critical concern, says Michael Daignault, an emergency physician who serves as chief medical adviser to Reliant Health Services, a medical testing company. He says that the nature of throat saliva could simply cause the test to display a message that the result is invalid rather than a false positive.
Another obvious potential problem, Manabe points out, is the length of the swab in some of the kits: "The swab that you use doesn't have a very long stick because it's just meant to be used in the front of your nose. So for you to get that into the back of your throat would not be very easy, truthfully, for some of the kits, depending on the length of the swab."
The public debate about the best way to swab has prompted a growing chorus of voices to call for new studies and a revamping of the kits and/or the instructions.
That kind of change is what Michal Tal is hoping for. Tal, an instructor at Stanford University's Institute for Stem Cell Biology and Regenerative Medicine and a visiting scientist at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, is a proponent of throat swabs. Before seeing anyone in person, she asks that they take a coronavirus test and swab not only their nose but their cheeks, the roof of their mouth, under their tongue and if they don't gag easily their throat near the tonsils.
"I'm feeling very frustrated that the FDA and CDC didn't jump on this and try to make more rapid changes," says Tal. "The virus is always two steps ahead and we don't adapt."
At a congressional hearing Monday, the acting head of the FDA, Dr. Janet Woodcock, noted that the National Institutes of Health has helped accelerate the authorization of new home tests so that they can get the FDA's signoff in just one or two days. But she said it may take a while for companies to change their test configurations to include larger swabs for the throat.
In the meantime, she warned people not to swab their throats with the current devices, which are designed as nasal swabs. "They may stab themselves," she said. "That would not be good."
Sheila Mulrooney Eldred is a freelance health journalist in Minneapolis. She has written about COVID-19 for many publications, including The New York Times, Kaiser Health News, Medscape and The Washington Post. More at sheilaeldred.pressfolios.com. On Twitter: @milepostmedia.
Hacking a home COVID test by adding a throat swab is a hot topic on Twitter : Goats and Soda - NPR
- Is a universal coronavirus vaccine on the horizon? - National Geographic - January 19th, 2022
- Boris Johnson says Englands virus rules will ease next week. - The New York Times - January 19th, 2022
- Coronavirus Roundup: One Year of the Biden COVID-19 Response - GovExec.com - January 19th, 2022
- Thousands in Hong Kong volunteer to adopt hamsters amid COVID-19 fears - Reuters - January 19th, 2022
- Coronavirus spreading like never before in Americas, health agency says - Reuters Canada - January 19th, 2022
- Here are the latest COVID-19 numbers for Wednesday, January 19 - WNEP Scranton/Wilkes-Barre - January 19th, 2022
- How does COVID-19 misinformation compare with other health topics? - Medical News Today - January 19th, 2022
- 538 more coronavirus cases have been reported across Maine - Bangor Daily News - January 19th, 2022
- Is headache a symptom of the omicron COVID variant? - FOX31 Denver - January 19th, 2022
- Omicron won't be the last COVID-19 variant, WHO says - WXYZ - January 19th, 2022
- The cGAS-STING pathway drives type I IFN immunopathology in COVID-19 - Nature.com - January 19th, 2022
- Lesson of the Day: At-Home Coronavirus Tests Are Inaccessible to Blind People - The New York Times - January 19th, 2022
- With many wondering whether Omicron means we're approaching the endemic phase of Covid-19, Fauci cautions it's still too soon to tell - CNN - January 18th, 2022
- Study on 4th COVID vaccine dose shows effectiveness; results against omicron unclear - WXYZ - January 18th, 2022
- Coronavirus in Ohio Monday update: Over 19,500 new cases, 2.4 million total - NBC4 WCMH-TV - January 18th, 2022
- Preparing for the endemic stage of COVID-19: What this looks like - KOIN.com - January 18th, 2022
- White House to offer free COVID tests beginning Wednesday how to get them - KXAN.com - January 18th, 2022
- COVID tests, other public service events on MLK Day in L.A. - Los Angeles Times - January 18th, 2022
- Covid loses 90% of ability to infect within 20 minutes in air study - The Guardian - January 18th, 2022
- Federal at-home COVID-19 tests will be available this week - KRIS Corpus Christi News - January 18th, 2022
- One year later: What symptoms do some COVID-19 patients still have? - WKBW-TV - January 18th, 2022
- Novel coronavirus - Wikipedia - January 16th, 2022
- Virus Outbreak: Covid (Coronavirus) News and Analysis From Jan. 15 - Bloomberg - January 16th, 2022
- Corona Virus SalzburgerLand.com - January 16th, 2022
- Protest in Netherlands against coronavirus measures - Reuters - January 16th, 2022
- For Coronavirus Testing, the Nose May Not Always Be Best - The New York Times - January 16th, 2022
- 14 more Mainers have died and another 1,359 coronavirus cases reported across the state - Bangor Daily News - January 16th, 2022
- Encouraging signs plan B Covid measures may soon be lifted in England - The Guardian - January 16th, 2022
- Experts warn against using Benadryl and milk to treat COVID, despite NC lawmakers post - KXAN.com - January 16th, 2022
- What do we know about the 175,000 people who died of Covid in the UK? - The Guardian - January 16th, 2022
- Coronavirus Data for January 12, 2022 | mayormb - Executive Office of the Mayor - January 16th, 2022
- How The mRNA Vaccines Were Made: Halting Progress and Happy Accidents - The New York Times - January 16th, 2022
- Brazil registers 48520 new cases of coronavirus and 175 deaths-health ministry - Reuters - January 16th, 2022
- 3 big Covid misconceptions people still have, according to infectious disease experts - CNBC - January 16th, 2022
- High demand for COVID testing calls Kauai War Memorial Convention Hall to action - KHON2 - January 16th, 2022
- The Covid Race to Watch: Vaccines vs. Variants - The Wall Street Journal - January 16th, 2022
- Coronavirus Data for January 11, 2022 | mayormb - Executive Office of the Mayor - January 13th, 2022
- Shawnee County Covid Indicator shows cases of coronavirus rising by more than 25% - KSNT News - January 13th, 2022
- Coronavirus in Ohio Thursday update: More than 19,000 new cases reported - NBC4 WCMH-TV - January 13th, 2022
- England cuts coronavirus isolation to 5 days - POLITICO Europe - January 13th, 2022
- COVID-19 in South Dakota: 2,584 total new cases; Death toll rises to 2,544; Active cases at 24,796 - KELOLAND.com - January 13th, 2022
- The Real Reason Americans Aren't Isolating - The Atlantic - January 13th, 2022
- China: Over 20 million in COVID-19 lockdown ahead of 2022 Olympics - NPR - January 13th, 2022
- Coronavirus in Arkansas: another record as over 10,000 new cases reported, 14 more deaths - KNWA - January 13th, 2022
- Utah surge ongoing with 12,990 new COVID-19 cases Thursday - fox13now.com - January 13th, 2022
- Increasing demand for coronavirus tests in Southern Oregon - KDRV - January 13th, 2022
- The Mood in the Capitol Was Already Dark. Then Came Omicron. - The New York Times - January 13th, 2022
- Information for travellers in regards to the corona virus ... - January 10th, 2022
- Corona Virus Update, Currently There Are 179 active ... - January 10th, 2022
- A Surge in Hospitalized Young Children Infected With the Coronavirus - The New York Times - January 10th, 2022
- Coronavirus in Ohio Sunday update: Just over 19,000 new cases and less than 100 new hospitalizations - WKBN.com - January 10th, 2022
- Coronavirus Briefing: A Pandemic of the Forgotten - The New York Times - January 10th, 2022
- COVID-19 surge has overwhelmed some Pa. hospitals and now their workers are getting sick, too - The Philadelphia Inquirer - January 10th, 2022
- Coronavirus: should the UK make vaccination mandatory? - The Guardian - January 10th, 2022
- COVID-19: UK records 141,472 new cases and further 97 coronavirus-related deaths - Sky News - January 10th, 2022
- Flu and Covid at the Same Time? Your 'Flurona' Questions, Answered - The New York Times - January 10th, 2022
- States are scrambling to keep up with an increase in Covid-19 hospitalizations and the demand for testing - CNN - January 10th, 2022
- Health experts want to focus on 'new normal' with the coronavirus | TheHill - The Hill - January 10th, 2022
- Chicago's COVID-19 fight with teachers hangs over a 2nd week - KMTV - 3 News Now - January 10th, 2022
- From delta to omicron, heres how scientists know which coronavirus variants are circulating in the US - KRQE News 13 - January 10th, 2022
- Coronavirus Watch: Oregon breaks COVID-19 case record for the third day running - KDRV - January 7th, 2022
- From delta to omicron, here's how scientists know which coronavirus variants are circulating in the US - The Conversation US - January 7th, 2022
- Understanding flurona: person has the flu and the coronavirus simultaneously - fox2now.com - January 7th, 2022
- Rapid nasal COVID tests feared to be returning false negatives - Axios - January 7th, 2022
- COVID infections hit another daily record in Louisiana as hospitalizations rise - The Advocate - January 7th, 2022
- Coronavirus Data for January 4, 2022 | mayormb - Executive Office of the Mayor - January 7th, 2022
- If you give yourself a COVID test, who tracks the results? - Los Angeles Times - January 7th, 2022
- How TV Shows Are Moving Past the Coronavirus Pandemic - The New York Times - January 7th, 2022
- COVID-19 testing in Massachusetts impacted due to snow - WWLP.com - January 7th, 2022
- Washington to expand access to coronavirus tests, to help contain spread of COVID-19 - KOMO News - January 7th, 2022
- Coronavirus Omicron variant, vaccine, and case numbers in the United States: Jan. 7, 2022 - Medical Economics - January 7th, 2022
- Coronavirus in Ohio Thursday update: Another day of more than 19,000 new cases - WKBN.com - January 7th, 2022
- COVID-19: Did Omicron evolve in mice? - Medical News Today - January 7th, 2022
- Hogan says 10 new hospital-based COVID testing sites to open in Maryland - WTOP - January 7th, 2022
- Outbreak hits Rhode Island hospital after COVID-positive staff called in to work - fox4kc.com - January 7th, 2022
- Swedens king and queen test positive for the coronavirus. - The New York Times - January 5th, 2022
- W.H.O. Downplays Threat From New Virus Variant in France - The New York Times - January 5th, 2022
- Omicron estimated to be 95.4% of coronavirus variants in U.S. - CDC - Reuters - January 5th, 2022
- US COVID cases are on the rise, but this doctor sees hope on the horizon : Coronavirus Updates - NPR - January 5th, 2022
- Late-night hosts Jimmy Fallon and Seth Meyers test positive for COVID-19 - NPR - January 5th, 2022