San Franciscos public schools have been virtual-only for nearly a year, despite increasing pressure from parents and politicians to reopen for in-person instruction. Even the city attorney has called on the school district to immediately reopen elementary schools.
The school district is set to vote on a plan Tuesday that would allow schools to reopen in Californias second-most-restrictive red tier once staff is fully vaccinated.
But local politicians say that plan is still too restrictive, given the reality that vaccinations are proceeding slowly because of lack of supply.
Some have noted that other major school districts across the U.S. have opened to some form of in-person schooling despite having higher levels of community transmission than San Francisco.
In New York City, where an average of 51 people per 100,000 are testing positive for the coronavirus every day, elementary schools have been open on a hybrid schedule for months, and middle schools are in the process of reopening. Other large school districts, including Atlanta and Miami, have fully reopened for elementary, middle and high school students (with remote learning options), despite having higher daily case rates than San Franciscos current rate of 9 per 100,000.
Supporters of San Franciscos prolonged closures have argued that keeping children and teachers at home is part of whats driving the citys low case rates, and that opening schools too quickly could lead to transmission among students and teachers.
We need a clear and coordinated state, county and local plan that puts the health and safety of our communities first and does not take shortcuts toward the path of opening schools in person, the California Teachers Association wrote in a letter to Gov. Gavin Newsom in late January as part of an effort to keep schools in counties under the states widespread purple tier closed for 100 days.
The idea that keeping schools closed has kept coronavirus numbers low isnt supported by the evidence, according to numerous Bay Area health experts.
There is not data to support that claim, Dr. Jeanne Noble, head of UCSFs emergency department COVID-19 response, said in an email. Noble cited a December study published by the CDC that found that, among children younger than 18 in Mississippi, attending school or child care did not make students more likely to test positive for the coronavirus. Instead, children who didnt consistently wear masks or had close contact with people outside of their household were more likely to test positive.
In fact, Noble said, the study found that kids who had gone to school or day care where masking was enforced during the previous 14 days were more likely to test negative for the coronavirus.
In other words, not only did attending in person not raise the risk for acquiring COVID, attending a school with universal masking actually lowered the childs risk for acquiring COVID, suggesting that schools may indeed be protective, she said.
In another recent study of 90,000 students and 10,000 teachers in North Carolinas school system, only 32 in-school transmissions occurred all of which were related to breaches in masking protocol, Noble said.
Carrie Byington, executive vice president of University of California Health, said the rate of coronavirus within a community remained an important factor when considering whether and how to reopen schools.
Case rates and other indicators of community transmission are important considerations when planning for school openings or any in-person activity, she said in an email.
But she agreed that opening schools was unlikely to drive San Franciscos infection rates up: There is now evidence from the U.S. and other countries that in-person school is not a primary driver of community transmission of SARS-CoV2, she said.
Some experts said that case rates a factor that the CDC has weighed heavily in its school reopening guide should not even be considered when making the decision to reopen.
We have seen major cities all over the country including New York, Chicago, Dallas, Houston, Washington DC, Miami, Philadelphia, Atlanta, and Boston open to some component of in-person learning (hybrid or full-time) despite much higher case rates than San Francisco without significant issues of school-based transmission, Dr. Mitul Kapadia, associate clinical professor of pediatrics at UCSF, said in an email.
Kapadia pointed out that many public schools in Marin County have been open since October, with more than 17,000 students attending school in-person on a daily basis. With similar case rates Marin Countys daily new case rate is at 12 per 100,000 residents Marin has seen minimal school-based transmission and zero transmissions from student to teacher, he said.
Safe school reopening can happen despite high levels of community transmission, Kapadia said. The biggest predictor of transmission within schools is consistent implementation of layered mitigation strategies particularly mask use and physical distancing.
Susie Neilson is a San Francisco Chronicle staff writer. Email: firstname.lastname@example.org Twitter: @Susieneilson
San Francisco has the lowest coronavirus case rate of major U.S. cities. But its schools are among the last to reopen - San Francisco Chronicle
- The search for animals harbouring coronavirus and why it matters - Nature.com - March 4th, 2021
- Which Coronavirus Variants Are In The US And How Worried Should We Be? : Shots - Health News - NPR - March 4th, 2021
- Brazil coronavirus variant capable of reinfecting those who already had COVID-19, research suggests - FOX 35 Orlando - March 4th, 2021
- Coronavirus tally: Global cases of COVID-19 top 114.8 million and U.S. death toll above 516,000 - MarketWatch - March 4th, 2021
- Coronavirus in N.J.: Whats reopened, what concerts, festivals and shows are rescheduled, canceled. (March 3, - NJ.com - March 4th, 2021
- The latest on coronavirus cases, regulations, and vaccination efforts in Texas - KENS5.com - March 4th, 2021
- The differences between the coronavirus vaccines, and is it fair to compare them? This Week in the CLE - cleveland.com - March 4th, 2021
- Senate trims parts of Biden's $1.9 trillion coronavirus relief bill before votes - The Union Leader - March 4th, 2021
- Pro Farmer's First Thing Today: Coronavirus Aid Bill, Vaccine Supply Update and More - Agweb Powered by Farm Journal - March 4th, 2021
- Over 100,000 North Dakotans have had a confirmed case of COVID-19 | INFORUM - INFORUM - March 4th, 2021
- Expert 'mortified and disgusted' by Texas reopening plan; it 'will kill Texans,' says top Democrat - MarketWatch - March 4th, 2021
- 2 more Mainers have died and another 147 coronavirus cases reported across the state - Bangor Daily News - March 4th, 2021
- Why The Coronavirus Did Not Bring The Financial Rout That Many States Feared - The New York Times - March 2nd, 2021
- Florida coronavirus: State reports lowest case increase since October - WFLA - March 2nd, 2021
- See how sharply Ohio coronavirus cases, hospitalizations have dropped, and vaccines increased; county and sta - cleveland.com - March 2nd, 2021
- Coronavirus in Ohio Monday: COVID-19 vaccine eligibility expanded to those 60+ as more doses made available - NBC4 WCMH-TV - March 2nd, 2021
- 75 million coronavirus vaccine doses administered in the US - WBNG-TV - March 2nd, 2021
- Coronavirus Vaccine Woes & the Anniversary We Never Wanted: What Happened in San Diego in February 2021 - NBC San Diego - March 2nd, 2021
- G League looking into claim made by Jeremy Lin that he was called 'coronavirus' on court - ESPN - March 2nd, 2021
- The Latest: Thailand begins COVID-19 vaccinations - KTIV - February 28th, 2021
- Opinion | The Final Push to End the Coronavirus Pandemic in the U.S. - The New York Times - February 28th, 2021
- Can vaccinated people still spread the coronavirus? - The Conversation US - February 28th, 2021
- Coronavirus response | Wheels of justice to resume grinding in Champaign County - Champaign/Urbana News-Gazette - February 28th, 2021
- The Religion of the City: Cars, Mass Transit and Coronavirus - ArchDaily - February 28th, 2021
- The Coronavirus Is Plotting a Comeback. Heres Our Chance to Stop It for Good. - The New York Times - February 26th, 2021
- Timeline: One year of coronavirus in Rhode Island - The Providence Journal - February 26th, 2021
- New Findings on 2 Ways Children Become Seriously Ill From the Coronavirus - The New York Times - February 26th, 2021
- Ukraine records 50% spike in coronavirus cases - WBNG-TV - February 26th, 2021
- Ohio coronavirus alert map improves for first time in weeks; 4 counties downgraded from red alert to orange - cleveland.com - February 26th, 2021
- Coronavirus Roundup: Administration To Deliver Millions of Masks; Agencies Have Yet to Implement Many of Watchdog's Recommendations - GovExec.com - February 26th, 2021
- Steuben County reports 15 new cases of COVID-19, more than 5,500 confirmed since last year - WETM - MyTwinTiers.com - February 26th, 2021
- 105-Year Old Woman Survived Spanish Flu, and Now, Coronavirus - The New York Times - February 24th, 2021
- Dallas County reports 412 coronavirus cases and 18 deaths, including woman in her 30s without underlying - The Dallas Morning News - February 24th, 2021
- Coronavirus: NYC movie theaters to reopen with limited capacity in March - KIRO Seattle - February 24th, 2021
- Central Europe braced for third wave of coronavirus - Financial Times - February 24th, 2021
- Paid To Stay Home Coronavirus Aid Bill Pays Federal Employees With Kids Out Of School Up To $21K - Forbes - February 24th, 2021
- Coronavirus has stolen some kids' sense of smell, and it stinks - The Colorado Sun - February 24th, 2021
- Who's in the next coronavirus vaccine priority group in Louisiana? Higher education, clergy, more - The Advocate - February 24th, 2021
- Thailand to start first coronavirus vaccinations this week - Reuters - February 24th, 2021
- A Simple Rule of Thumb for Knowing When the Pandemic Is Over - The Atlantic - February 24th, 2021
- Positive Coronavirus Test? Canadians Worry Their Neighbors Will Find Out - The New York Times - February 22nd, 2021
- More than 20 cases of U.K. and South African COVID-19 variants found in South Carolina - WLTX.com - February 22nd, 2021
- How Will the Coronavirus Evolve? - Scientific American - February 20th, 2021
- COVID-19 surge is now helping to create herd immunity - Los Angeles Times - February 20th, 2021
- Tampa will have one of four FEMA coronavirus vaccination sites in Florida - Tampa Bay Times - February 20th, 2021
- Breath analyzer test deployed to help better screen coronavirus - University of Miami - February 20th, 2021
- Biden To Give $4 Billion To COVAX, Global COVID-19 Vaccine Effort - NPR - February 20th, 2021
- L.A. to expand mobile vaccination clinics in areas hardest hit by coronavirus - KTLA - February 20th, 2021
- U.K. Approves Study That Will Infect Volunteers With Covid - The New York Times - February 18th, 2021
- True toll of coronavirus on sub-Saharan Africa may be obscured by tremendous variability in risk factors and surveillance - Princeton University - February 18th, 2021
- Red tier could be in sight as Orange County coronavirus metrics improve - Los Angeles Times - February 18th, 2021
- Coronavirus: Tourism thrives in Mexico against the odds - DW (English) - February 18th, 2021
- U.S.S. Theodore Roosevelt Has New Coronavirus Outbreak - The New York Times - February 18th, 2021
- Tracking COVID-19 in Alaska: 40 cases and 1 death reported Wednesday - Anchorage Daily News - February 18th, 2021
- Gwyneth Paltrow Reveals She Had COVID-19 Early on, and Shes Still Dealing With Symptoms - Prevention.com - February 18th, 2021
- W.H.O. Researcher Seeking Coronavirus Origins on His Trip to China - The New York Times - February 18th, 2021
- Garnar to hold weekly coronavirus briefing (Feb. 17) - WBNG-TV - February 18th, 2021
- Should I get the COVID-19 vaccine while breastfeeding? - WTOL - February 18th, 2021
- Sen. Sherrod Brown wants pension fix included in coronavirus relief bill - cleveland.com - February 18th, 2021
- Low coronavirus cases fuel hopes that organized sports will resume on Oahu - KHON2 - February 18th, 2021
- The coronavirus is here to stay here's what that means - Nature.com - February 16th, 2021
- Coronavirus in Michigan: Heres what to know Feb. 16, 2021 - WDIV ClickOnDetroit - February 16th, 2021
- Key Florida official overseeing COVID-19 response resigns - Wink News - Wink News - February 16th, 2021
- New Zealand On Alert As A Family Tests Positive For The Coronavirus : Coronavirus Updates - NPR - February 16th, 2021
- Covid-19 conspiracy theories and the superspreaders behind them - syracuse.com - February 16th, 2021
- 6 graphs to illustrate Ohio coronavirus trends for vaccines, hospitalizations, deaths and cases: mid-February - cleveland.com - February 16th, 2021
- Coronavirus will have lasting impact on restaurant industry - Food Safety News - February 16th, 2021
- New CDC school guidelines amid coronavirus: 4 key things to know - SILive.com - February 16th, 2021
- More than half of all COVID-19 cases in Michigan prisons are in Ionia County - Fox17 - February 16th, 2021
- Town of Secaucus - Corona Virus Information - February 14th, 2021
- Coronavirus in 3D, mutation origins and India invests in virology - Nature.com - February 14th, 2021
- Coronavirus Australia live news: Pfizer doses to arrive this week, Australia on track for vaccine rollout in late February - ABC News - February 14th, 2021
- 22 New Cases of Coronavirus UK Variant Found In CT: Heres Where - Patch.com - February 14th, 2021
- Health Care Workers Hit Hard by the Coronavirus Pandemic - The New York Times - February 14th, 2021
- Coronavirus: Latest developments in the Greater Toronto Area on Feb. 13 - Global News - February 14th, 2021
- Memphis surgeon dies of COVID-19 related illness weeks after receiving second vaccine - WAVY.com - February 14th, 2021
- Coronavirus in Michigan: Heres what to know Feb. 12, 2021 - WDIV ClickOnDetroit - February 12th, 2021
- CDC Says Double-Masking Offers More Protection Against The Coronavirus - NPR - February 12th, 2021
- Why all the world's coronavirus would fit in a can of cola - BBC News - February 12th, 2021
- Coronavirus Contextualized, 39th edition: Cases, hospitalizations continue to decrease though still double what they were in September - The Nevada... - February 12th, 2021