Updated at 1:21 p.m. ET on July 13, 2021.
The first thing to know about the COVID-19 vaccines is that theyre doing exactly what they were designed and authorized to do. Since the shots first started their rollout late last year, rates of COVID-19 disease have taken an unprecedented plunge among the immunized. We are, as a nation, awash in a glut of spectacularly effective vaccines that can, across populations, geographies, and even SARS-CoV-2 variants, stamp out the most serious symptoms of disease.
The second thing to know about the COVID-19 vaccines is that theyre flame retardants, not impenetrable firewalls, when it comes to the coronavirus. Some vaccinated people are still getting infected, and a small subset of these individuals is still getting sickand this is completely expected.
Were really, really bad at communicating that second point, which is all about breakthroughs, a concept that has, not entirely accurately, become synonymous with vaccine failure. Its a problem that goes far beyond semantics: Bungling the messaging around our shots astounding success has made it hard to convey the truly minimal risk that the vaccinated face, and the enormous gamble taken by those who eschew the jabs.
The main problem is this. As the CDC defines it, the word breakthrough can refer to any presumed infection by SARS-CoV-2 (that is, any positive coronavirus test) if its detected more than two weeks after someone receives the final dose of a COVID-19 vaccine. But infections can come with or without symptoms, making the term imprecise. That means breakthroughs writ large arent the most relevant metric to use when were evaluating vaccines meant primarily to curb symptoms, serious illness, hospitalizations, and death. Breakthrough disease is what the average person needs to be paying attention to, Cline Gounder, an infectious-disease physician at Bellevue Hospital Center in New York, told me. Silent, asymptomatic breakthroughsthose that are effectively invisible in the absence of a virus-hunting diagnosticare simply not in the same league.
To put this in perspective, consider the original criteria laid out by the FDA about this time last year, back when the United States was still solidly in its second infectious surge. An effective inoculation, the agency said, should be able to prevent disease or decrease its severity in at least 50 percent of people who are vaccinated. Its an easy benchmark to forget. By the close of 2020, two vaccines absolutely obliterated those expectations; two months later, a third followed, and now theres buzz of a fourth.
If disease is our yardstick, then breakthrough COVID-19 casesa very small subset of all known breakthroughsmight meet our criteria for concern. These are actual illnesses, events where the shots protection has apparently crumbled; these cases are the same ones that vaccine makers searched so diligently for in clinical trials, to ensure that their products were working. By the same logic, asymptomatic coronavirus infections fall outside our shots protective purview as we defined it so many months ago. And although theyre important to track and glean data from, conflating them with the rest, experts told me, risks misrepresenting what our vaccines can do. (The CDC responded to an inquiry about its designation by saying that while a SARS-CoV-2 infection indicates any positive tests for the virus and a COVID case refers to a person with a positive test who meets other case definitions, throughout COVID the terms infection and case have often been used interchangeably.)
Read: Heres why breakthroughs happen
The term breakthrough has long been a staple of the infectious-disease community, where its used to describe the detection of vaccine-preventable pathogens in immunized individuals. This is definitely not a new idea, says Kevin Escandn, a physician and infectious-disease researcher at the University of Valle, in Colombia. But as a popular notion, it was always doomed to cause some confusion. Breakthrough is still used as an adjective of praise; the pandemic has now warped the word into a foreboding noun that tends to eclipse all clarifying qualifiers. Its confusing, its fuzzy, its already loaded, Alison Buttenheim, who studies human behavior around vaccines at the University of Pennsylvania, told me. And when news appears in a headline or push alert, or on social media, people pay attention to the word breakthrough and not much else, Ryan McNamara, a virologist at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, told me. Thats unfortunate, when the simple addition of asymptomatic or symptomatic can make all the difference. As they stand, blanket breakthroughs sound far scarier than they should.
Joseph Allen, a public-health researcher at Harvard, recently pointed out on Twitter one such ambiguity, in a study documenting a very small number of breakthrough infections at a prison. All were asymptomaticthough you wouldnt know it from the papers title.
To be clear, breakthroughs of any severity are an entirely expected part of the vaccination process. No vaccines are 100 percent effective at preventing infection or disease. But our current crop of COVID-19 shots comes pretty damn close with regards to stymieing symptoms, especially the severe ones that can signal a deadly case. The Moderna and Pfizer shots have consistently demonstrated very high COVID-prevention rates, often in the 90s; Johnson & Johnsons, for the most part, isnt far behind. Symptomatic breakthroughs are the cases that wedge themselves in the gap between excellent effectiveness and perfect effectiveness; in other words, we saw them coming.
Even out in the messiness of the real world, symptomatic breakthrough cases are proving themselves quite rare. The overwhelming majority of the COVID-19 cases were seeing are among the unvaccinated. And when the virus does affect the immunized, it seems to accumulate to lower levels, and spread less enthusiastically to new hosts; its causing, on average, milder and more transient symptoms.
All of this is a reminder of how vaccines workby ratcheting up our immunity against the version of SARS-CoV-2 that the shots were formulated to mimic. If humans are wood that fuels a flame, and coronaviruses are the sparks that ignite it, vaccines are the fire suppressants that protect best against the worst of the viral burn: severe disease, hospitalization, and death. Stopping milder cases requires more immune investment, and blocking asymptomatic infectionsones that barely singe the barkis most difficult of all. Its part of why the vaccines goalposts were at first set so conservatively. This is not a magic shield that just bounces coronavirus right off you, McNamara told me.
Considering that we first took aim at stopping disease, its great news that the majority of known breakthroughs have actually been asymptomatic infections, not COVID-19 cases. The proportions of silent breakthroughs reported by various studies and federal agencies are certainly undercounts, because vaccinated people arent regularly screened for the coronavirus. (On May 1, the CDC controversially switched its reporting strategy to documenting only breakthrough cases involving some form of hospitalization or death, skewing national counts further.) Since the vaccines first deployed, the news has only improved: Researchers didnt bank on it, but in many people, the shots seem to stop the coronavirus from establishing itself at all. The vaccines are better than anything we ever dreamed of, Gounder told me, exceeding our first expectations in more ways than one.
The shots are even holding their own against SARS-CoV-2 variants. A few versions of the virus have picked up mutations that help them dodge certain anti-coronavirus antibodies. But these genetic alterations chip away only incrementally at immune protection, rather than obliterating it. Against Delta, for instance, vaccines like Pfizers are still curbing severe disease, hospitalization, and death to an extraordinary degree. And while the shots strength has slightly slackened when it comes to milder illnesses and silent infections, those are simply lower hurdles for a virus to clear. Pfizers protection is still hitting its mark where it matters the most. (One asterisk on this is long COVID, a condition whose relationship to vaccination is still being actively researched.)
None of this means, of course, that asymptomatic breakthrough infections should be ignored. To fully understand what the virus is doing and where it might be headed, experts need as comprehensive a picture as they can get of whom its afflicting, and what form those infections take, across the entire spectrum of disease. They also need to know how and when its most likely to spread. Asymptomatic infections are a part of that. Researchers around the world are still diligently sequencing any and all test-positive coronavirus samples they can, regardless of symptoms, in part to check whether any particular variants are disproportionately infiltrating the inoculated. Theyre also tabulating whos experiencing breakthroughs, and testing whether select populations might benefit from an early vaccine boost.
Read: What breakthrough infections can tell us
And when vaccines start to consistently falter against more severe tiers of diseasebecause of either a new variant, waning immune memory of the virus, or boththe diligent monitoring of breakthroughs will pick it up. Tracking milder breakthroughs is also crucial to figuring out how well the virus can be transmitted from vaccinated people, something thats much more difficult to determine than whether inoculations merely block disease. From a surveillance standpoint, casting a broad net for breakthroughsone that accounts for infections of all typesis essential, Buttenheim said. Thats how you catch everything.
The question of which breakthroughs matter ultimately depends on another: Whats the goal of vaccination? Gounder thinks that, for now, the focus should stay on using immunizations to control COVID-19, especially while so much of the world remains unvaccinated; understanding whether were accomplishing that goal, then, hinges on symptomatic breakthroughs. Eventually, well have the bandwidth to turn our attention to halting transmission and infection more comprehensively. Then, well pull asymptomatic breakthroughs back into the conversation, with more data to guide our next move.
Read the original:
What Counts as a COVID-19 Breakthrough Case? - The Atlantic
- Why Vaccinated People Are Getting Breakthrough Infections - The New York Times - July 24th, 2021
- Coronavirus in Illinois: 7,983 New COVID Cases, 47 Deaths, 139K Vaccinations in the Past Week - NBC Chicago - July 24th, 2021
- 31 Children Test Positive for Coronavirus at Summer Camp in NY - The New York Times - July 24th, 2021
- They Live in an N.Y.C. Virus Hot Spot. But They Wont Get Vaccinated. - The New York Times - July 24th, 2021
- Positive Coronavirus Test Halts Shakespeare in the Park for Third Night - The New York Times - July 24th, 2021
- Coronavirus Watch: Common respiratory viruses are on the rise, CDC warns - USA TODAY - July 24th, 2021
- China Has Rejected A WHO Plan For Further Investigation Into The Origins Of COVID-19 - NPR - July 24th, 2021
- COVID-19: What you need to know about the coronavirus pandemic on 23 July - World Economic Forum - July 24th, 2021
- CT hospitality jobs struggling to recover from the coronavirus - The CT Mirror - July 24th, 2021
- We may finally know why the delta variant of coronavirus is so infectious - Livescience.com - July 24th, 2021
- The coronavirus cuts cells hairlike cilia, which may help it invade the lungs - Science News Magazine - July 24th, 2021
- Texas veterans homes overseen by George P. Bush were often the deadliest places to be during COVID-19 pandemic - The Texas Tribune - July 24th, 2021
- Coronavirus and the global recovery: the dangers of whiplash economics - Financial Times - July 24th, 2021
- Public Health Officials Announce 7,983 New Cases of Coronavirus Disease Over the Past Week | IDPH - IDPH - July 24th, 2021
- Coronavirus infection rates in these South Shore communities are among highest in NYC - SILive.com - July 24th, 2021
- Olympics 2021 COVID-19 tracker: Everyone who has tested positive for coronavirus at the Games - CBS Sports - July 24th, 2021
- Covid-19 vaccines are effective at preventing severe disease, experts say, as rising cases threaten unvaccinated - CNN - July 24th, 2021
- Coronavirus Roundup: Concerns About the Delta Variant Rise; Administration Will 'Continue to Follow the Science' for Agency Reentry Plans -... - July 24th, 2021
- Coexisting with the Coronavirus - The New Yorker - July 22nd, 2021
- Sixth Texas Democrat in Washington, D.C., tests positive for COVID-19 - The Texas Tribune - July 22nd, 2021
- What Is A Breakthrough COVID Case, And How Big Is The Risk? : Shots - Health News - NPR - July 22nd, 2021
- Coronavirus: US extends travel limits at borders with Canada and Mexico - as it happened - Financial Times - July 22nd, 2021
- Coronavirus Data for July 20, 2021 | mayormb - Executive Office of the Mayor - July 22nd, 2021
- 1st U.S. Athlete Set To Compete In Olympics Tests Positive For Coronavirus In Japan - NPR - July 22nd, 2021
- Death rates soar in Southeast Asia as virus wave spreads - Associated Press - July 22nd, 2021
- Scarred by Covid, Survivors and Victims Families Aim to Be a Political Force - The New York Times - July 22nd, 2021
- Two-thirds of Indians have coronavirus antibodies, survey shows - Reuters India - July 22nd, 2021
- Coco Gauff tests positive for the virus, another blow for the Tokyo Olympics. - The New York Times - July 22nd, 2021
- Cats Are Better Than Dogs (at Catching the Coronavirus) - The New York Times - July 20th, 2021
- Oregon sees 777 new coronavirus cases over the weekend, nine more COVID deaths - KATU - July 20th, 2021
- Coronavirus: Canada paves way for tourists to return starting in August - as it happened - Financial Times - July 20th, 2021
- COVID-19: Vallance corrects mistake to say 60% of people being admitted to hospital with coronavirus are unvaccinated - Sky News - July 20th, 2021
- The latest on the Covid-19 pandemic as Olympics approach: Live updates - CNN - July 20th, 2021
- Coronavirus Roundup: Smithsonian and National Archives Advance Reopenings; Court Sides with CDC on Cruises - GovExec.com - July 20th, 2021
- Despite Positive COVID-19 Results, Team USA Will Be Ready For Tokyo Olympics : Live Updates: The Tokyo Olympics - NPR - July 20th, 2021
- Coronavirus today: The weekend continued the dangerous trend; deaths top 6,000 in Arkansas - Arkansas Times - July 20th, 2021
- Factbox: Coronavirus outbreaks at the Tokyo Olympics - Reuters - July 20th, 2021
- 3 Texas Dems test positive for coronavirus while in D.C. - POLITICO - July 20th, 2021
- Three Texas House Democrats who traveled to Washington, D.C., test positive for coronavirus - The Texas Tribune - July 18th, 2021
- Fauci says natural origins theory of coronavirus is still the most likely - CNN - July 18th, 2021
- COVID by the Numbers: Coronavirus Metrics in Each of Illinois' Health Care Regions - NBC Chicago - July 18th, 2021
- Yankees Game Postponed After Positive Covid Tests - The New York Times - July 18th, 2021
- 'Bridgerton' and Coronavirus: Positive Tests Halt Production in UK - The New York Times - July 18th, 2021
- The Latest: 3 lawmakers who fled Texas over vote have virus - Associated Press - July 18th, 2021
- Germany lists Greece and the Netherlands as coronavirus risk areas -RKI - Reuters - July 18th, 2021
- COVID-19: What you need to know about the coronavirus pandemic on 16 July - World Economic Forum - July 18th, 2021
- Majority of Covid misinformation came from 12 people, report finds - The Guardian - July 18th, 2021
- What to Know About the Coronavirus Beta Variant - Healthline - July 18th, 2021
- Coronavirus Data for July 15, 2021 | mayormb - Executive Office of the Mayor - July 18th, 2021
- Florida adds 45,604 coronavirus cases, 231 deaths in the past week - Tampa Bay Times - July 18th, 2021
- Coronavirus: Canada set to overtake US in terms of fully vaccinated population as it happened - Financial Times - July 18th, 2021
- Led Study Helps in the Fight Against the Coronavirus Pandemic - United States Geological Survey - July 15th, 2021
- Many Jobs Lost During the Coronavirus Pandemic Just Arent Coming Back - The Wall Street Journal - July 15th, 2021
- Coronavirus Today: Where are the COVID-19 treatments? - Los Angeles Times - July 15th, 2021
- Coronavirus returns to Kingston Healthcare Center, a local nursing home notorious for its handling of the pandemic - KGET 17 - July 15th, 2021
- Myanmar sees record coronavirus deaths and infections - Reuters - July 15th, 2021
- Statement on the eighth meeting of the International Health Regulations (2005) Emergency Committee regarding the coronavirus disease (COVID-19)... - July 15th, 2021
- Unvaccinated may require tougher tactics amid COVID-19 surge - Los Angeles Times - July 15th, 2021
- COVID-19: What you need to know about the coronavirus pandemic on 13 July - World Economic Forum - July 14th, 2021
- Coronavirus (COVID-19) Update: July 13, 2021 - FDA.gov - July 14th, 2021
- One mutation may have set the coronavirus up to become a global menace - Science News Magazine - July 14th, 2021
- A Woman Died Of COVID After Contracting 2 Variants At The Same Time, Researchers Say - NPR - July 14th, 2021
- Death Toll Rises to 92 in Fire That Gutted Iraq Hospital Coronavirus Ward - The New York Times - July 14th, 2021
- Summer camps hit with COVID outbreaks are schools next? - Associated Press - July 14th, 2021
- Summer Vacation Is Not Going to Keep Coronavirus at Bay. Only Jabs Will. - Bloomberg - July 14th, 2021
- Coronavirus Data for July 9-11, 2021 | mayormb - Executive Office of the Mayor - July 14th, 2021
- Lambda Variant Of Covid-19 Coronavirus Is Spreading, What You Need To Know - Forbes - July 11th, 2021
- FLORIDA Florida reports rise in coronavirus cases over the past week WINK NEWS - Wink News - July 11th, 2021
- Breath-Based Coronavirus Tests Are Being Developed - The New York Times - July 11th, 2021
- Coronavirus cases in the Netherlands surge more than 800% in one week - BNO News - July 11th, 2021
- Halloween Haunt, Winterfest returning to Kings Island this fall after coronavirus cancellation - dayton.com - July 11th, 2021
- Americans will need masks indoors as U.S. heads for 'dangerous fall' with surge in delta Covid cases - CNBC - July 11th, 2021
- COVID-19: What you need to know about the coronavirus pandemic on 9 July - World Economic Forum - July 11th, 2021
- Coronavirus survivors: Wed like to hear your story of resilience and courage - SILive.com - July 11th, 2021
- Headache? Runny nose? These are among the new top 5 Covid symptoms, study says - CNBC - July 9th, 2021
- COVID-19 In Maryland: More Than 100 New Cases Reported Friday - CBS Baltimore - July 9th, 2021
- OC Residents and Businesses Grapple With Masks, Vaccine Verification Policies Amid Coronavirus Reopening - Voice of OC - July 9th, 2021
- Officials Tighten Restrictions In Seoul Amid Another Wave Of COVID-19 Infections - NPR - July 9th, 2021
- Coronavirus: Inbound travelers to isolate until receiving test results - The Jerusalem Post - July 9th, 2021
- The Latest: New Zealand gives tentative OK for 2nd vaccine - The Associated Press - July 7th, 2021